Feed trap-shy cats out of unset traps in their normal feeding locations for a week or two before trapping again. Start with the food right by the entrance of the trap and gradually move it closer to the back each day.

Cats don’t like to feel trapped or boxed in. A larger trap with a taller opening and wider sides can be more inviting to a cat wary of entering an enclosed space.

By placing a dark towel over the trap, without blocking the door, you create a space that looks dark, hidden, and safe to cats.

Something extra smelly and tasty, and perhaps out of the ordinary, might pique a cat’s interest. We have lots of suggestions for safe and tasty treats! Try jarred baby food, canned mackerel, or chicken.

Coax wary cats into the trap with a trap of tiny food scraps leading up to and then inside the trap. Gradually increase the size of the bait scraps as you place them on the trigger plate and beyond. Make sure you don’t use too much; you don’t want the cat to get full before she reaches the trigger plate! You can also try using the smelly broth of canned cat food or meats as your bait trail.